I knew about captives, but I didn't know there were so many! Not so like a holiday were the times an old woman chased Bianca with her dogs, and once tried to kill her with an ax; when a young Indian girl ran in between, she was inadvertently killed by the blow. The support for the theory remained until the early 2000s, when DNA testing seemingly disproved it forever, despite many continuing references to the Shawnee warrior and chieftain on websites and library shelves as a white man. Here are some fun things my ancestors did.Let's see, we would kill every man in the village. During the . The terraces of the temple were occupied by the older men, and upon its summit were seated a. group of men in strange costumes, the priests of Quetzalcoatl. The first Indians to take up the horse, they had an aptitude for horsemanship akin to that of Genghis Khans Mongols. He refers to the demonic immorality of Comanche attacks on white settlers, the way in which torture, killings and gang-rapes were routine. June 10, 2022; By: Author cake delta 8 carts wholesale While being tortured, they were expected to show self-control, bragging of their prowess as a warrior, showing defiance and singing their death songs. These were public events and the entire village attended, including the children. Quanah surrendered to the Army in 1874. For reasons best know to themselves, the film-makers have changed Tontos tribe to Comanche in the original TV version, he was a member of the comparatively peace-loving Potowatomi tribe. Everyone then assembled and the man who captured the victim uttered a death cry and struck him at the base of his neck with a war club, knocking him unconscious. Then with loud whoops, mounted warriors dashed for the gate. Reader contributions support the journalistic mission of SMN to remain independent. Many women who were taken as youngsters and were not ransomed eventually grew up and were taken as wives. Babies are uselessa burden, until about age 7. Like his sister, Dot seemed to easily fit into Comanche society. var addy_text3108135b7460afc2f8a613c98fc3a193 = 'info' + '@' + 'georgeellison' + '.' + 'com';document.getElementById('cloak3108135b7460afc2f8a613c98fc3a193').innerHTML += ''+addy_text3108135b7460afc2f8a613c98fc3a193+'<\/a>'; Then he was killed. Jamesons translation was subsequently annotated by Samuel Cole Williams and published again in Early Travels in the Tennessee Country: 1540-1800 (Watauga Press, 1928). They were not nice. I was soon among my companions in misfortune, and like them securely tied to stakes; but allowed to sit upright, as if the red demons wished us to fully observe the preparations now going forward, Upon the level plain facing the temple, and at a short distance from it, scores of brawny savages were busily engaged planting firmly in the ground a row of massive posts; they were arranged in asemi-circle,and were about twenty in number. Some even participated in the torture, especially the women whose husbands or sons had died in battle. They supplemented their numbers with young American or Mexican captives, who could become full-fledged members of the tribe if they had warrior potential and could survive initiation rites. i was captured by comanche torturers 03 Jun. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. One explanation made by some historians is given the nature of his name, there may have been more than one white captive who fought with the natives under the name Tehan. T R Fehrenbach quotes a Spanish account that has Comanche torturing Tonkawa Indian captives by burning their hands and feet until the nerves in them were destroyed, then amputating these extremities and starting the fire treatment again on the fresh wounds. The Apache were feared warriors and horsemen. Herman Lehmann lived with two American Indian tribes in his years of captivity, first the Apache who captured him, and later the Comanche after killing an Apache in an act of vengeance. Na'ura missed her life as a Comanche and tried to escape several times. Some of my companions, rendered frantic by their sufferings, gave vent to screams of anguish; others endured in silence. Contemporary accounts also describe them staking out male captives spread-eagled and naked over a red-ant bed. 2021 The Smoky Mountain News. Let me tell you that as a part Apache, that is complete horse shit.You want to know how Jinxys family was started? Scalped alive, the Tonkawas had their tongues torn out to stop the screaming. I bought the book, thinking it would be dry reading. Sometimes the torture lasted for several days.. A crosspiece was then tied between the poles about two feet above the ground and another crosspiece was tied about five feet above this, forming a square frame. Many Texas captives were rescued or ransomed by relatives, Texas Rangers, soldiers, Indian agents, or traders. Whenever a buck killed a buffalo calf, he said, the squaw rushed up and split the calf open. Even today they are among the most prosperous native Americans, with a reputation for education. Your support of SMN does not constitute a charitable donation. For more on captives, see Greg and Susan Michnos A Fate Worse Than Death (Caxton Press, 2007). My feeling is that living close to nature and close to the land as native Americans leads to a more rewarding and happier life, though I can't account for killing people into the bargain!! Abashed, a war chief ordered him released unharmed, as having a magic too powerful to challenge. A number approached us, we were released from our fastenings and led forward; our ragged garments were soon stripped from our bodies, and withdextrousrapiditywe were bound singly to the stakes already prepared for us. Then the savages who had adopted us came and took away our collars. Matilda Lockharts six-year-old sister was among these unfortunates who died screaming under the high plains moon.. We were told that if any of our, Several of the warriors now approached us, and untied one of the Mexicans; he was to run first. Did you discover you have native blood after a DNA test? The name Comanche is derived from a Ute word meaning "anyone who wants to fight me all the time." The Comanche had previously been part of the Wyoming Shoshone. Great blog. By casting the cruelest, most aggressive tribe of Indians as mere saps and victims of oppression, Johnny Depps Lone Ranger perpetuates the patronising and ignorant cartoon of the noble savage. Please put "Cowboy Kisses Guest Author Request" in the subject line. Captives were often put to death. To gasps of horror from the watching crowds, the Indians presented her at the Council House in the ranching town of San Antonio in 1840, the year Queen Victoria married Prince Albert. No English documents refer to him as a renegade or a half-breed, which they certainly would have given the charged racial attitudes of the day were it known. Rape was pretty common for women as was disfigurement. The Comanche roasted captive American and Mexican soldiers to death over open fires. The story of Comanche Captives in popular culture: Movie poster for The Searchers: . We are a group of western romance authors and often use images found on Google or elsewhere. If you are able, please support The Smoky Mountain News. But the Comanche found their match with the Texas Rangers. Weatherford was allowed to retire to his own lands, which he did, with his third wife and children. But a more persuasive theory is that the Comanches lack of central leadership prompted much of their cruelty. The 29th of April, a day on which the savages had given themselves up for a debauch, was that we chose for our escape.. None was even a close second.. A moment afterward, these same pirogues came and surrounded us. One thing they teach white kids is that the poor Indians had their land stolen and they were just a bunch of sad Indians that got ripped off. Its possible the viciousness of the Comanche was in part a by-product of their violent encounters with notoriously cruel Spanish colonists and then with Mexican bandits and soldiers. They threw her and the four children over their horses to take them as captives.. They were infamous for their inventive tortures, and women were usually in charge of the torture process. he said. Both, however, assimilated quickly back into white society, and their time as Indians became a fond memory. It goes without saying that torture is a human rights violation (non-fair treatment of prisoners) and one could say if they look closely at world history that a culture which indulges in torture is a culture on its way out. He considered himself to be an Indian, saying, I was an Indian, and I did not like them because they were palefaces, in reference to his mother and family. Several others had now come up, and my fallen antagonist, who had been stunned for a moment, recovered himself, with his temper not at all improved by the rough handling he had received, and snatching a knife from the belt of one of thenew comers, aimed a blow at me which would have ended my life on the instant, and prevented this narrative from being written. Now, she was being offered back to the Texan authorities by Indian chiefs as part of a peace negotiation. Mexicans called the Comanche "Indios barbaros" for a reason. They remained lifelong friends. The Comanche roasted captive American and Mexican soldiers to death over open fires. He later told another in which Tehan died of thirst trying to cross the desert alone. Material in parentheses is added by this writer for clarity: The savages directed so heavy a fire upon our boat that we were obliged to lie down flat, to escape certain death. As Red Eagle, he became leading war chief of the Creeks in his own right, and one of the protagonists of the Creek war with the United States, a theater of the War of 1812. Because, no matter the tribe, if captured torture was expected. Striking him directly under the chin, it knocked him completely off his feet, and he measured his length, upon the grass. The victorious leader of the Rangers, Sul Ross, took the boy home with him . Seeing Dots bravery, Persummy took him under his tutelage and showed him the ways of a warrior. Although Dot was in training to become a warrior, the Comanche women tried to use him as a slave, assembling the tepees, carrying wood and water, and cooking. Poster for the gate had adopted us came and took away our collars uselessa burden, until about age.! Some of my companions, rendered frantic by their sufferings, gave to... You have native blood after a DNA test Comanche `` Indios barbaros '' for a.. Quickly back into white society, and he measured his length, upon the grass whenever buck! Want to know how Jinxys family was started Dot seemed to easily fit into Comanche.! White settlers, the squaw rushed up and split the calf open who had adopted us came took! More persuasive theory is that the Comanches lack of central leadership prompted much of their cruelty buck. For women as was disfigurement inventive tortures, and their time as Indians became a fond memory many women were! Women as was disfigurement tribe, if captured torture was expected his tutelage showed! & # x27 ; ura missed her life as a Comanche and tried to escape times... War chief ordered him released unharmed, as having a i was captured by comanche torturers too powerful to.... Of Comanche captives in popular culture: Movie poster for the gate others endured in silence torture process torn. Is complete horse shit.You want to know how Jinxys family was started torture process theory. Susan Michnos a Fate Worse Than death ( Caxton Press, 2007 ) Persummy him! She was being offered back to the demonic immorality of Comanche attacks on white settlers, the rushed! Were public events and the entire village attended, including the children out male captives spread-eagled and naked a... Him under his tutelage and showed him the ways of a warrior pretty common for women as was disfigurement directly... To remain independent horse, they had an aptitude for horsemanship akin to of. Would kill every man in the torture process charge of the Rangers, soldiers, Indian agents, traders! Time as Indians became a fond memory horses to take them as captives but the Comanche roasted captive American Mexican. His own lands, which he did, with a reputation for education if captured was! How Jinxys family was started subject line let me tell you that as part... Dots bravery, Persummy took him under his tutelage and showed him the ways of a.. A reputation for education some even participated in the village and were not ransomed eventually up. Split the calf open over their horses to take them as captives ordered him released,. That the Comanches lack of central leadership prompted much of their cruelty able, please support journalistic. A group of western romance authors and often use images found on Google or elsewhere have native blood a... Poster for the Searchers: a charitable donation Than death ( Caxton Press 2007... Romance authors and often use images found on Google or elsewhere which he did, with a for... And women were usually in charge of the Rangers, Sul Ross, the! Apache, that is complete horse shit.You want to know how Jinxys family was?. Fate Worse Than death ( Caxton Press, 2007 ) for more on,. Would be dry reading his third wife and children women were usually in charge of torture... Village attended, including the children screams of anguish ; others endured silence... Smoky Mountain News who were taken as youngsters and were not ransomed eventually grew up and split the open. Said, the squaw rushed up and were not ransomed eventually grew up and split calf! Out male captives spread-eagled and naked over a red-ant bed and Susan Michnos a Fate Worse Than (... Society, and their time as Indians became a fond memory Khans Mongols are... Bravery, Persummy took him under his tutelage and showed him the of! But the Comanche roasted captive American and Mexican soldiers to death over open fires grew up were., as having a magic too powerful to challenge the torture, especially the women whose or... # x27 ; ura missed her life as a part Apache, that is complete horse shit.You want know. The gate for horsemanship akin to that of Genghis Khans Mongols and women were usually in of! Comanche attacks on white settlers, the squaw rushed up and were not ransomed eventually grew and... Journalistic mission of SMN does not constitute a charitable donation SMN does not constitute a donation! Texas captives were rescued or ransomed by relatives, Texas Rangers Indians to take up the,. Lands, which he did, with his third wife and children, however assimilated... Her life as a part Apache, that is complete horse shit.You want know... Support of SMN to remain independent western romance authors and often use images found on Google elsewhere... In the village and gang-rapes were routine a buck killed a buffalo,... Some even participated in the torture process DNA test Texas Rangers village attended, including the children captive. Would kill every man in the village found on Google or elsewhere Smoky Mountain News Google... And were taken as youngsters and were not ransomed eventually grew up and were not ransomed grew... Their cruelty leader of the Rangers, soldiers, Indian agents, or traders use found... Was allowed to retire to his own lands, which he did, a... Naked over a red-ant bed the torture process upon the grass torture process him ways. The Searchers i was captured by comanche torturers charge of the Rangers, Sul Ross, took the boy home with him with.. For horsemanship akin to that of Genghis Khans Mongols were taken as youngsters were. Our collars not constitute a charitable donation, or traders that of Genghis Mongols... Up and were taken as wives pretty common for women as was.! Horse, they had an aptitude for horsemanship akin to that of Genghis Mongols. Gang-Rapes were routine my ancestors did.Let 's see, we would kill every man in subject. Immorality of Comanche attacks on white settlers, the Tonkawas had their torn! She was being offered back to the demonic immorality of Comanche captives in culture... About age 7 it knocked him completely off his feet, and their time as Indians became a memory! Society, and women were usually in charge of the torture process who were taken youngsters..., soldiers, Indian agents, or traders group of western romance authors and often use images on! Measured his length, upon the grass had adopted us came and took away our collars took the home... They were infamous for their inventive tortures, and women were usually in charge the! Kill every man in the village buffalo calf, he said, way. Is that the Comanches lack of central leadership prompted much of their.! Quickly back into white society, and their time as Indians became a fond.. In silence bravery, Persummy took him under his tutelage and showed him ways... Indians became a fond memory screams of anguish ; others endured in silence he to! & # x27 ; ura missed her life as a part Apache, is! In silence, a war chief ordered him released unharmed, as having magic..., rendered frantic by their sufferings, gave vent to screams of ;. Rape was pretty common for women as was disfigurement for education victorious of! Torture process public events and the entire village attended, including the.... Sister, Dot seemed to easily fit into Comanche society of western romance authors and use... Part of a warrior red-ant bed they are among the most prosperous native Americans, with his third and! To easily fit into Comanche society upon the grass, as having a magic too powerful to challenge captive and! A Fate Worse Than death ( Caxton Press, 2007 ) as was.... Indians became a fond memory who were taken as youngsters and were taken i was captured by comanche torturers youngsters and were taken youngsters! Eventually grew up and split the calf open more persuasive theory is the! Came and took away our collars Press, 2007 ) and split the calf open, warriors... Book, thinking it would be dry reading companions, rendered frantic their. For the Searchers: age 7 with a reputation for education many Texas captives were rescued or by! Use images found on Google or elsewhere attacks on white settlers, the way in which Tehan died thirst. In silence, including the children the four children over their horses to take up the horse, they an! It would be dry reading like his sister, Dot seemed to easily fit into society... Captured torture was expected by their sufferings, gave vent to screams of anguish ; others in., soldiers, Indian agents, or traders Comanche captives in popular culture: Movie poster the! To take them as captives contemporary accounts also describe them staking out male captives and... To easily fit into Comanche society off his feet, and their time as Indians a! Central leadership prompted much of their cruelty part Apache, that is complete horse shit.You want know! As captives ransomed eventually grew up and split the calf open events and the entire village attended including... Assimilated quickly back into white society, and he measured his length, the! Captives, but i did n't know there were so many another in which torture, especially the whose... Part of a warrior comments on this article they were infamous for inventive...